Dave Meltzer has reviewed and given his ratings for AEW All Out 2024.
As published in the latest edition of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Meltzer has given his thoughts and star ratings for the matches that took place inside the Now Arena in Hoffman Estates, Illinois on September 7th, 2024.
The lowest-rated match of the card was in the pre-show which saw the team of Anthony Bowens and Max Caster win over Bronson and Boulder which earned just *¼. The highest-rated match was the AEW International Championship match between Will Ospreay and Pac which furthered Ospreay’s record of most five-star rated or higher matches to 42 as the match earned *****½.
Dave Meltzer’s AEW All Out 2024 Star Ratings Are As Follows:
Pre Show:
- The Acclaimed (Anthony Bowens and Max Caster) (with Billy Gunn) defeated Iron Savages (Bronson and Boulder) (with Jacked Jameson) – *¼
- Hologram, Sammy Guevara, and Dustin Rhodes defeated The Premier Athletes (Tony Nese, Ari Daivari, and Josh Woods) (with “Smart” Mark Sterling) – **¾
- Bang Bang Gang (Austin Gunn, Colten Gunn, and Juice Robinson) defeated The Dark Order (Evil Uno, Alex Reynolds, and John Silver) – **¾
- The Undisputed Kingdom (Matt Taven, Mike Bennett, and Roderick Strong) defeated The Beast Mortos and Shane Taylor Promotions (Shane Taylor and Lee Moriarty) and Action Andretti and Top Flight (Dante Martin and Darius Martin) (with Leila Grey) – ***½
Main Card:
- MJF defeated Daniel Garcia – ****½
- AEW World Tag Team Title Match: The Young Bucks (Matthew Jackson and Nicholas Jackson) (c) defeated Blackpool Combat Club (Claudio Castagnoli and Wheeler Yuta) – ****
- AEW Intercontinental Title Match: Will Ospreay (c) defeated Pac – *****½
- Chicago Street Fight Match: Kris Statlander (with Stokely Hathaway) defeated Willow Nightingale – ****¾
- AEW Continental Title Match: Kazuchika Okada (c) defeated Mark Briscoe, Orange Cassidy, and Konosuke Takeshita (with Don Callis) – ****¼
- AEW TBS Title Match: Mercedes Moné (c) defeated Hikaru Shida – **¾
- AEW World Title Match: Bryan Danielson (c) defeated Jack Perry – ****¾
- Lights Out Steel Cage Match: “Hangman” Adam Page defeated Swerve Strickland (with Prince Nana) – ****½
What Backstage Incident Occurred At AEW All Out?
A backstage incident reportedly occurred at AEW All Out between an unnamed wrestler and a member of the production crew. It was reported that after the Chicago Street Fight Match security personnel could be seen running backstage to break up the alleged incident.