Ohio local trial court judicial elections, 2016

From Ballotpedia
Jump to: navigation, search
Trial-Courts-Ballotpedia.png

2016 Local Judicial Elections

View judicial elections by state:

Elections Information
Election datesState judicial elections
Poll opening and closing times

Fifty-seven Ohio counties held nonpartisan general elections for 114 courts of common pleas seats on November 8, 2016. Contested primary elections took place on March 15, 2016, for just 12 of those seats.

While the general elections were held on nonpartisan ballots, the primaries were partisan. Only one common pleas court in the entire state saw enough candidates file for both the Democrats and Republicans to require that both parties hold a primary.

County judges in Ohio are elected to six-year terms. Candidates had to file with their county's board of elections by December 16, 2015, to run in the partisan primaries. Candidates could have filed as independents, in which case they were not required to file until March 14, 2016. Independent candidates did not appear in the primary elections; they only appeared on the general election tickets.[1]

Seats on Ohio's state-level appeals courts were also up for election in 2016. Click here for more information about those elections.

HIGHLIGHTS
  • The primary date was moved to align with Ohio's presidential primary.
  • A total of 164 partisan candidates filed; 99 seats were unopposed in the primary election.
  • Two seats saw no partisan candidates file for their primaries.
  • Races and candidates by county

    Adams

    Adams County

    Incumbent Judge Brett Spencer (D) won re-election unopposed, as no Republican or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    Brett Spencer (i)[2]

    Primary election

    Brett Spencer Democratic Party (i)[3]

    Allen

    Allen County

    Incumbents Jeffrey Reed (R) and Matt Staley (R) were unopposed in their primary elections for the General and Domestic Division seats. They were also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge them.

    General election

    General Division

    Jeffrey Reed (i)[4]

    Domestic Division

    Matt Staley (i)[4]

    Primary election

    General Division

    Jeffrey Reed Republican Party (i)[4]

    Domestic Division

    Matt Staley Republican Party (i)[4]

    Ashland

    Ashland County

    General Division incumbent Ronald Forsthoefel (R) won re-election unopposed. No Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    Ronald Forsthoefel (i)

    Primary election

    Ronald Forsthoefel Republican Party (i)[5]

    Athens

    Athens County

    General election

    George McCarthy (i)

    Primary election

    George McCarthy Republican Party (i)[6]

    Auglaize

    Auglaize County

    Republican incumbent Frederick Pepple was entirely unopposed in his re-election bid.

    General election

    Frederick Pepple (i)

    Primary election

    Frederick Pepple Republican Party (i)[7]

    Butler

    Butler County

    All four Bulter County incumbents won re-election unopposed.

    General election

    General Division

    Greg Stephens (i)[8]

    Domestic Relations Division
    (Two seats)

    Barbara Carter (i)[8]
    Margot Halcomb (i)

    Juvenile Division

    Kathleen Dobrozsi Romans (i)[8]

    Primary election

    General Division

    Greg Stephens Republican Party (i)[8]

    Domestic Relations Division
    (Two seats)

    Barbara Carter Republican Party (i)[8]
    Margot Halcomb Republican Party (i)

    Juvenile Division

    Kathleen Dobrozsi Romans Democratic Party (i)[8]

    Clark

    Clark County

    General Division incumbents Richard O'Neill (D) and Douglas Rastatter (R) won re-election unopposed. No independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division (Two seats)

    Richard O'Neill Democratic Party (i)
    Douglas Rastatter Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division (Two seats)

    Richard O'Neill Democratic Party (i)[9]
    Douglas Rastatter Republican Party (i)

    Clermont

    Clermont County

    General Division incumbent Judge Thomas R. Herman (R) did not file to seek re-election. Anthony Brock won the open seat. Domestic Relations Division Judge Kathleen Rodenberg (R) was also unopposed in her re-election bid.[10]

    General election

    General Division

    Anthony Brock

    Domestic Relations Division[11]

    Kathleen Rodenberg (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[11]

    Anthony Brock Republican Party

    Domestic Relations Division[11]

    Kathleen Rodenberg Republican Party (i)

    Columbiana

    Columbiana County

    Incumbent Judge Scott Washam (R) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    Scott Washam (i)

    Primary election

    Scott Washam Republican Party (i)[12]

    Coshocton

    Coshocton County

    Incumbent Bob Batcheler (R) saw no challengers from his own party or from the Democrats in the primary election.

    General election

    Bob Batcheler (i)

    Primary election

    Bob Batcheler Republican Party (i)[13]

    Cuyahoga

    Cuyahoga County

    One Republican and 12 Democrats won their general elections unopposed after seeing unopposed primaries. Only three seats saw contested primaries, and only for the Democratic candidates. No independent candidates filed for any of these court seats.

    The three Domestic Relations Division seats all had contested general election races with a Democrat and a Republican for each seat. Alternatively, the three Juvenile Division seats were all won by unopposed Democratic incumbents.

    Just three of the 13 General Division seats were contested on the general election ballot. The other 10 were decided at the primary ballot. The defeat of sitting judge Michael Astrab (D) in the primary was the most significant of the March outcomes. Astrab filed to run for a different General Division than the one he currently held. Despite being ranked higher by Judge4Yourself.com than the other three candidates in the field for his new targeted seat, Astrab placed last in the primary election.

    General election

    General Division[14]

    Ambrose seat
    Dick Ambrose (i)
    Astrab seat
    Michael Shaughnessy
    Clancy seat
    Maureen Clancy (i)
    Brian Corrigan seat
    Brian Corrigan (i)
    Peter Corrigan seat
    Peter Corrigan (i)
    Donnelly seat
    Michael Donnelly (i)
    Gall seat
    Steve Gall(i)
    Gallagher seat
    Hollie Gallagher (i)
    Matia seat
    David Matia (i)
    Mason seat
    Sherrie Miday
    Matthew McMonagle
    Russo seat
    John Russo (i)
    Synenberg seat
    Joan Synenberg (i)
    Andrea Nelson Moore
    Villanueva seat
    Kelly Ann Gallagher
    James Cochran

    Domestic Relations Division[14]

    Goldberg seat
    Francine Goldberg (i)
    John Mayer
    Karner seat
    Tonya Jones
    Janet Rath Colaluca
    Palos seat
    Diane Palos (i)
    Donna Coury

    Juvenile Division[14]

    Corrigan seat
    Patrick Corrigan (i)
    Ryan seat
    Michael Ryan (i)
    Sweeney seat
    Kristin Sweeney (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[14]

    Ambrose seat
    Dick Ambrose Republican Party (i)
    Astrab seat
    Joseph Russo Democratic Party
    James Satola Democratic Party
    Michael Shaughnessy Democratic Party
    Clancy seat
    Maureen Clancy Democratic Party (i)
    Brian Corrigan seat
    Brian Corrigan Democratic Party (i)
    Peter Corrigan seat
    Peter Corrigan Democratic Party (i)
    Donnelly seat
    Michael Donnelly Democratic Party (i)
    Gall seat
    Steve Gall Democratic Party (i)
    Gallagher seat
    Hollie Gallagher Democratic Party (i)
    Matia seat
    David Matia Democratic Party (i)
    Mason seat
    Sherrie Miday Democratic Party
    Matthew McMonagle Republican Party
    Russo seat
    John Russo Democratic Party (i)
    Synenberg seat
    Joan Synenberg Republican Party (i)
    Andrea Nelson Moore Democratic Party
    Villanueva seat
    Michael Astrab Democratic Party
    Pablo Castro Democratic Party
    Kelly Ann Gallagher Democratic Party
    Mary Brigid Sweeney Democratic Party
    James Cochran Republican Party

    Domestic Relations Division[14]

    Goldberg seat
    Francine Goldberg Democratic Party (i)
    John Mayer Republican Party
    Karner seat
    Tonya Jones Democratic Party
    Michael O'Shea Democratic Party
    Janet Rath Colaluca Republican Party
    Palos seat
    Diane Palos Democratic Party (i)
    Donna Coury Republican Party

    Juvenile Division[14]

    Corrigan seat
    Patrick Corrigan Democratic Party (i)
    Ryan seat
    Michael Ryan Democratic Party (i)
    Sweeney seat
    Kristin Sweeney Democratic Party (i)

    Darke

    Darke County

    General Division incumbent Judge Jonathan Hein (R) won re-election unopposed, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Jonathan Hein (i)

    Primary election

    General Division

    Jonathan Hein Republican Party (i)[15]

    Delaware

    Delaware County

    Delaware County has two general, one probate/juvenile and one domestic relations division seats on its common pleas bench. The Domestic Relations Division was created in 2015 to address the high caseload of the court's General Division. The 2016 election determined the new seat's first officeholder.[16]

    Two Republicans filed for the seat. There were no Democratic or independent candidates.

    General election

    Domestic Relations Division

    Randall Fuller

    Primary election

    Domestic Relations Division[17]

    Randall Fuller Republican Party
    Christopher Geer Republican Party

    Erie

    Erie County

    General Division incumbents Tygh Tone (D) and Roger Binette (R) won re-election in the general election after both running unopposed in their respective partisan primaries. No independent candidates filed to run in the general election.

    General election

    General Division (Two seats)

    Tygh Tone (i)
    Roger Binette (i)

    Primary election

    General Division (Two seats)[18]

    Tygh Tone Democratic Party (i)
    Roger Binette Republican Party (i)

    Fayette

    Fayette County

    General and Domestic Relations Division incumbent Judge Steven Beathard (R) won re-election unopposed, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General and Domestic Relations Division

    Steven Beathard (i)

    Primary election

    General and Domestic Relations Division[19]

    Steven Beathard Republican Party (i)

    Franklin

    Franklin County

    Six of the nine seats up for election on the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas were guaranteed to be contested in the general election after both Democrats and Republicans filed for them. None of the seats, however, saw more than one candidate from either of the major parties, meaning all the primaries were unopposed. No independent candidates filed for any of the contests.[20]

    Two Republican candidates withdrew from their races after the primary: incumbent Patrick Sheeran and challenger Andy Hall. The Republican Party selected Lauren Dolan and Stephanie Hanna to take their places in the general election.[20]

    General election

    General Division[21]

    Beatty seat
    Laurel Beatty (i)
    Valoria Hoover - Withdrawn
    Cocroft seat
    Kimberly Cocroft (i)
    Lauren Dolan
    Replacement candidate for Republican Party following the withdrawal of Andy Hall
    Frye seat
    Richard Frye (i)
    Donald Kline
    Holbrook seat
    Michael Holbrook (i)
    Crysta Pennington
    Lynch seat
    Julie Lynch (i)
    O'Donnell seat
    Colleen O'Donnell (i)
    Serrott seat
    Mark Serrott (i)
    Sheeran seat
    Jeffrey Brown
    Stephanie Hanna
    Replacement candidate for Republican Party following the withdrawal of incumbent Patrick Sheeran

    Domestic Division[21]

    Kim Browne (i)
    Jim Reese

    Primary election

    General Division[21]

    Beatty seat
    Laurel Beatty Democratic Party (i)
    Valoria Hoover Republican Party
    Cocroft seat
    Kimberly Cocroft Democratic Party (i)
    Andy Hall Republican Party
    Frye seat
    Richard Frye Democratic Party (i)
    Donald Kline Republican Party
    Holbrook seat
    Michael Holbrook Republican Party (i)
    Crysta Pennington Democratic Party
    Lynch seat
    Julie Lynch Republican Party (i)
    O'Donnell seat
    Colleen O'Donnell Republican Party (i)
    Serrott seat
    Mark Serrott Democratic Party (i)
    Sheeran seat
    Patrick Sheeran Republican Party (i)
    Jeffrey Brown Democratic Party

    Domestic Division[21]

    Kim Browne Republican Party (i)
    Jim Reese Democratic Party

    Fulton

    Fulton County

    General Division incumbent Judge James E. Barber (R) did not file to seek re-election in 2016. Jeffrey Robinson (R) won the seat unopposed, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Barber seat
    Jeffrey Robinson Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[22]

    Barber seat
    Jeffrey Robinson Republican Party

    Gallia

    Gallia County

    Incumbent D. Dean Evans (R) did not file to seek re-election due to the age restriction for judges in Ohio. Margaret Evans (R) was unopposed in the partisan primaries, but faced an independent challenger, William Medley, in the general election. No Democrats filed for the race.[23]

    General election

    General Division

    D. Dean Evans seat
    Margaret Evans
    William Medley

    Primary election

    General Division[24]

    D. Dean Evans seat
    Margaret Evans Republican Party

    Geauga

    Geauga County

    Carolyn Paschke (R) won David L. Fuhry's (R) General Division seat unopposed in the general election, after winning less than 34 percent of the votes cast in her party's primary. She faced no challenger on the general election ballot, as the only Democratic candidate withdrew prior to the primaries and no independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Carolyn Paschke Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[25]

    Fuhry seat
    Alison King - Withdrawn Democratic Party
    Mary Matheney Republican Party
    David Ondrey Republican Party
    Carolyn Paschke Republican Party
    Mark Porter Republican Party

    Greene

    Greene County

    Republican incumbents Mike Buckwalter and Adolfo Tornichio may be unopposed in their re-election bids; neither faced a primary challenger. They were also unopposed in the general election as no Democrats of independents filed for either race.[26]

    General election

    General Division

    Mike Buckwalter (i)

    Juvenile Division[27]

    Adolfo Tornichio (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[27]

    Mike Buckwalter Republican Party (i)

    Juvenile Division[27]

    Adolfo Tornichio Republican Party (i)

    Guernsey

    Guernsey County

    Incumbent David Ellwood (R) did not file to seek re-election. Daniel Padden (R) was unopposed to replace Ellwood in the general election. He did not face a primary challenge, and no Democrats or independents filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Ellwood seat
    Daniel Padden Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[28]

    Ellwood seat
    Daniel Padden Republican Party

    Hamilton

    Hamilton County

    At least three seats on the Hamilton County Court of Common Pleas were contested in the general election. Four General Division, two Domestic Relations Division and one Juvenile Division seat were up for election.

    Three incumbents won their seats outright in the primaries after being unopposed in their partisan races and having no opposition from the other party or independent candidates. Three seats saw both Democratic and Republican primaries, ensuring contested races on the general election. An additional independent candidate filing raised the number of contested general elections up by one.[29]

    General election

    General Division[30]

    Nadine Allen seat
    Lisa Allen
    Michael Mann
    Luebbers seat
    Jody Luebbers (i)
    Ruehlman seat
    Robert Ruehlman (i)
    Darlene Rogers
    Shanahan seat
    Megan Shanahan (i)
    Alvertis Bishop
    West seat
    Peter Stackpole
    Tom Heekin

    Domestic Relations Division[30]

    Sieve seat
    Jon Sieve (i)
    Tolbert seat
    Susan Tolbert (i)

    Juvenile Division[30]

    Hunter seat
    Darrell Payne
    Melissa Powers

    Primary election

    General Division[30]

    Luebbers seat
    Jody Luebbers Democratic Party (i)
    Ruehlman seat
    Robert Ruehlman Republican Party (i)
    Shanahan seat
    Megan Shanahan Republican Party (i)
    Alvertis Bishop Democratic Party
    West seat
    Peter Stackpole Democratic Party
    Tom Heekin Republican Party

    Domestic Relations Division[30]

    Sieve seat
    Jon Sieve Republican Party (i)
    Tolbert seat
    Susan Tolbert Republican Party (i)

    Juvenile Division[30]

    Hunter seat
    Darrell Payne Democratic Party
    Melissa Powers Republican Party

    Hardin

    Hardin County

    Incumbent Judge Scott Barrett (R) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General Division

    Scott Barrett Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[31]

    Scott Barrett Republican Party (i)

    Henry

    Henry County

    Incumbents John Collier (R) and Denise McColley (D) were unopposed in their respective primary elections. They were also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent candidates filed to challenge either sitting judge.

    General election

    General Division

    John Collier Republican Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division[32]

    Denise McColley Democratic Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[32]

    John Collier Republican Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division[32]

    Denise McColley Democratic Party (i)

    Jackson

    Jackson County

    Incumbent Judge Christopher Regan (R) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions

    Christopher Regan Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions[33]

    Christopher Regan Republican Party (i)

    Knox

    Knox County

    Incumbent Otho Eyster (R) did not seek re-election. No Democratic or independent candidates filed for her open seat, leaving two Republican newcomers to face off in the primary election. Primary winner Richard Wetzel Jr. (R) was unopposed in November.[34]

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Richard Wetzel Jr.

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[35]

    Eyster seat
    Noel Alden Republican Party
    Richard Wetzel Jr. Republican Party

    Licking

    Licking County

    Republican incumbent Duke Frost faced Democratic challenger Philip Proctor in the general election. Neither candidate faced a primary challenge, and no independent candidates filed for the race.[36]

    General election

    Domestic Division

    Duke Frost (i)
    Philip Proctor

    Primary election

    Domestic Division[37]

    Duke Frost Republican Party (i)
    Philip Proctor Democratic Party

    Logan

    Logan County

    Incumbent judges William Goslee (R) and Dan Bratka (R) were unopposed in their primary elections for the General and Family Division seats. They were also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge them.

    General election

    General Division

    William Goslee Republican Party

    Family Division

    Dan Bratka Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[38]

    William Goslee Republican Party

    Family Division[38]

    Dan Bratka Republican Party (i)

    Lorain

    Lorain County

    Two of Lorain County's Court of Common Pleas seats went to newcomers due to an open seat and a primary loss by an incumbent. General Division Judge Michele Silva Arredondo (R) lost to primary challenger Will Spiegelberg (R). Spiegelberg faced Chris Cook (D) in the general election. Gerry Phillips filed as an independent for that race, but his candidacy petition was disqualified by the county board of elections. Domestic Division Judge Debra L. Boros (R) did not seek re-election, leaving her seat open to a new judge.[39]

    General election

    General Division[40]

    Arredondo seat (Unexpired term)
    Chris Cook
    Will Spiegelberg
    Betleski seat
    Mark Betleski (i)
    Rothgery seat
    Christopher Rothgery (i)

    Domestic Division[40]

    Boros seat
    Sherry Glass Strohsack
    Krista Marinaro

    Primary election

    General Division[40]

    Arredondo seat (Unexpired term)
    Chris Cook Democratic Party
    Michele Silva Arredondo Republican Party (i)
    Will Spiegelberg Republican Party
    Betleski seat
    Mark Betleski Democratic Party (i)
    Rothgery seat
    Christopher Rothgery Democratic Party (i)
    James Burge Democratic Party

    Domestic Division[40]

    Boros seat
    Ben Davey Democratic Party
    Sherry Glass Strohsack Democratic Party
    David Graves Democratic Party
    Jenifer Berki Republican Party
    Krista Marinaro Republican Party

    Lucas

    Lucas County

    Three of the four incumbents up for election in Lucas County ran for re-election in 2016. Ruth Ann Franks (D) was the only incumbent who did not file for the election. Franks' open seat was the only contested race on the general election ballot, as no independent candidates filed for any of the races.[41]

    General election

    General Division

    Franks seat
    Lindsay Navarre
    Shelly Kennedy

    Goulding seat
    Michael Goulding (i)

    Mandros seat
    Dean Mandros (i)

    Zmuda seat
    Gene Zmuda (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[42]

    Franks seat
    Lindsay Navarre Democratic Party
    Shelly Kennedy Republican Party

    Goulding seat
    Michael Goulding Republican Party (i)

    Mandros seat
    Dean Mandros Democratic Party (i)

    Zmuda seat
    Gene Zmuda Republican Party (i)

    Madison

    Madison County

    General/Domestic Relations Division incumbent Judge Eamon Costello (R) won re-election unopposed, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Eamon Costello Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[43]

    Eamon Costello Republican Party (i)

    Mahoning

    Mahoning County

    Republican incumbents Shirley Christian and Theresa Dellick were unopposed in their party's primary. Anthony D'Apolito (D) ran against Christian for the General Division seat. No Democrats filed to run against Dellick for the Juvenile Division seat. Neither race drew independent candidate filings.[44]

    General election

    General Division

    Shirley Christian (i)
    Anthony D'Apolito

    Juvenile Division

    Theresa Dellick (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[45]

    Shirley Christian Republican Party (i)
    Anthony D'Apolito Democratic Party

    Juvenile Division

    Theresa Dellick Republican Party (i)

    Marion

    Marion County

    Republican incumbent Deborah Alspach was unopposed in her party's primary, and no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.[46]

    General election

    Probate/Juvenile Division

    Deborah Alspach (i)

    Primary election

    Probate/Juvenile Division[47]

    Deborah Alspach Republican Party (i)

    Medina

    Medina County

    Incumbent Christopher Collier (R) was initially unopposed in his re-election bid after no official Republican or Democratic challengers filed for the partisan primary. Michael Conway, however, filed for and ran a successful write-in campaign for the Democratic Party nomination in this race. No independent candidates filed for the general election, leaving Collier and Conway to go head-to-head in November.

    General election

    General Division I

    Christopher Collier Republican Party (i)
    Michael Conway Democratic Party

    Primary election

    General Division I[48]

    Christopher Collier Republican Party (i)
    Michael Conway (write-in) Democratic Party

    Mercer

    Mercer County

    Incumbent Judge Jeffrey Ingraham (D) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Republican candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Jeffrey Ingraham Democratic Party (i)

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[49]

    Jeffrey Ingraham Democratic Party (i)

    Monroe

    Monroe County

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Selmon seat
    Julie R. Selmon (i)

    Primary election

    There were no partisan filings for this seat. Therefore, no primary elections were held for the seat. Incumbent Julie R. Selmon was the only independent candidate to file for the race, leaving her unopposed in the general election.

    Montgomery

    Montgomery County

    Sitting Democratic judges Anthony Capizzi and Mary Wiseman were unopposed in their primaries for their Juvenile and General Division seats. Capizzi, however, faced the sole Republican challenger Ralph Wilcoxson on the general election ballot. Wiseman was unopposed in the general as no Republican or independent candidates filed for the General Division race.

    General election

    General Division

    Mary Wiseman Democratic Party (i)

    Juvenile Division

    Anthony Capizzi Democratic Party (i)
    Ralph Wilcoxson Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[50]

    Mary Wiseman Democratic Party (i)

    Juvenile Division[50]

    Anthony Capizzi Democratic Party (i)
    Ralph Wilcoxson Republican Party

    Morrow

    Morrow County

    Incumbent Judge Howard E. Hall (R) did not seek re-election in 2016. Tom Elkin (R) was unopposed in the primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.[51]

    General election

    Tom Elkin Republican Party

    Primary election

    Tom Elkin Republican Party

    Muskingum

    Muskingum County

    Republican incumbent Kelly Cottrill was unopposed in his party's primary and the general election, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Kelly Cottrill Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[52]

    Kelly Cottrill Republican Party (i)

    Paulding

    Paulding County

    General/Domestic Relations Division incumbent Tiffany Beckman saw no partisan candidates file for her seat. She was also the only independent candidate to file for the nonpartisan general election. Meanwhile, Probate/Juvenile Division incumbent John A. DeMuth did not file for re-election. Michael Wehrkamp (R) won his partisan primary unopposed, and no Democratic candidates filed for the open seat. Wehrkamp faced an independent challenger, John A. DeMuth, on the general election ballot.[53]

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Tiffany Beckman (i)

    Probate/Juvenile Division

    Michael Wehrkamp
    John A. DeMuth

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    No partisan candidates filed for this race.

    Probate/Juvenile Division[54]

    Michael Wehrkamp Republican Party

    Pike

    Pike County

    Incumbent Judge Randy Deering (D) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Republican candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Randy Deering Democratic Party (i)

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[55]

    Randy Deering Democratic Party (i)

    Portage

    Portage County

    Incumbent judges Laurie Pittman (D) and Paula Giulitto (D) were unopposed in their primary elections for the General and Domestic Relations Division seats. They were also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Republican candidates filed to challenge them.

    General election

    General Division

    Laurie Pittman Democratic Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division

    Paula Giulitto Democratic Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[56]

    Laurie Pittman Democratic Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division[56]

    Paula Giulitto Democratic Party (i)

    Putnam

    Putnam County

    No independent candidates filed for the General/Domestic Relations Division seat up for election. The unopposed Democratic and Republican primary winners faced each other for the open seat being vacated by Randall Basinger (D).

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Todd Schroeder Democratic Party
    Keith Schierloh Republican Party

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[57]

    Todd Schroeder Democratic Party
    Keith Schierloh Republican Party

    Richland

    Richland County

    All three Richland County incumbents won re-election unopposed, as each incumbent was the only partisan candidate to file for each race and no independent candidates filed for their races.

    General election

    General Division[58]

    Brent Robinson Republican Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division[58]

    Heather Cockley Democratic Party (i)

    Juvenile Division[58]

    Ron Spon Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[58]

    Brent Robinson Republican Party (i)

    Domestic Relations Division[58]

    Heather Cockley Democratic Party (i)

    Juvenile Division[58]

    Ron Spon Republican Party (i)

    Ross

    Ross County

    Incumbent Judge Michael Ater (R) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General Division

    Michael Ater Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[59]

    Michael Ater Republican Party (i)

    Seneca

    Seneca County

    Incumbents Michael Kelbley (D) and Steve Shuff (R) were unopposed in their primary elections. They were also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent candidates filed to challenge them.

    General election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions (Two seats)

    Michael Kelbley Democratic Party (i)
    Steve Shuff Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions (Two seats)[60]

    Michael Kelbley Democratic Party (i)
    Steve Shuff Republican Party (i)

    Stark

    Stark County

    Jason Reese (D) and Dave Nist (R) vied for the Family Court and Juvenile Divisions seat held by Michael L. Howard (R). General Division incumbent Chryssa Hartnett (D) was unopposed. No independent candidates filed for either race.

    General election

    General Division[61]

    Chryssa Hartnett Democratic Party (i)

    Family Court Division[61]

    Jason Reese Democratic Party
    Dave Nist Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[61]

    Chryssa Hartnett Democratic Party (i)

    Family Court and Juvenile Divisions[61]

    Jason Reese Democratic Party
    Dave Nist Republican Party

    Summit

    Summit County

    The two seats up for election in Summit County saw one Democrat and one Republican candidate each. No independent candidates filed for either race.

    General Division incumbent Todd McKenney (R) ran for re-election. Domestic Relations Division incumbent Carol J. Dezso (D) did not file to run for a new term.

    General election

    General Division

    McKenney seat
    Todd McKenney (i)
    Alison Breaux
    Parker unexpired term
    Scot Stevenson (i)
    Joy Malek Oldfield

    Domestic Relations Division[62]

    Ron Cable
    Katarina Vujic Cook

    Primary election

    General Division[62]

    McKenney seat
    Todd McKenney Republican Party (i)
    Alison Breaux Democratic Party

    Domestic Relations Division[62]

    Ron Cable Democratic Party
    Katarina Vujic Cook Republican Party

    Parker unexpired term

    Judge Thomas Parker was elevated to the United States District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, effective March 25, 2016, 10 days after the partisan primary date. Ohio's Revised Code provided that parties could nominate candidates for the race by August 15, 2016. Independent candidates, meanwhile, had to file by April 4, 2016, to run for the seat.[63]

    In June 2016, Republican Scot Stevenson was appointed to fill the seat until the election could be held. It was announced at that time that he would seek the remainder of the term in the general election against Democratic Akron Municipal Judge Joy Malek Oldfield.[64]

    Trumbull

    Trumbull County

    Incumbent Judge W. Wyatt McKay (D) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Republican candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General Division

    W. Wyatt McKay Democratic Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[65]

    W. Wyatt McKay Democratic Party (i)

    Tuscarawas

    Tuscarawas County

    Republican incumbent Elizabeth Lehigh Thomakos was unopposed in her party's primary and the general election, as no Democratic or independent candidates filed for the race.

    General election

    General Division

    Elizabeth Lehigh Thomakos Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General Division[66]

    Elizabeth Lehigh Thomakos Republican Party (i)

    Van Wert

    Van Wert County

    General/Domestic Relations Division Incumbent Judge Martin D. Burchfield (R) was unopposed in his primary election. He was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge him.

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[67]

    Martin D. Burchfield Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Martin D. Burchfield Republican Party (i)

    Vinton

    Vinton County

    Republican incumbent Jeffrey Simmons was entirely unopposed in his re-election bid.

    General election

    General/Domestic Relations Division

    Jeffrey Simmons (i)

    Primary election

    General/Domestic Relations Division[68]

    Jeffrey Simmons Republican Party (i)

    Warren

    Warren County

    The Warren County judicial races were decided in the primary election as only Republican candidates filed for the partisan primaries and no independent candidates filed for the general election. General Division incumbent Mike Gilb lost his bid for a full-term on the bench; he had been appointed in June 2015 to fill a vacancy on the court. Timothy Tepe defeated Gilb.

    Meanwhile, Domestic Relations Division incumbent Tim Oliver (R) did not seek re-election. Newcomer Jeffrey Kirby won the seat in the primary election.

    General election

    General Division[69]

    Timothy Tepe Republican Party

    Domestic Relations Division[69]

    Jeffrey Kirby Republican Party

    Primary election

    General Division[69]

    Mike Gilb Republican Party (i)
    Andrew Sievers Republican Party
    Timothy Tepe Republican Party

    Domestic Relations Division[69]

    Lauren Clouse Republican Party
    Jeffrey Kirby Republican Party

    Washington

    Washington County

    Mark Kerenyi (R) defeated two other Republicans in the primary. He advanced to face Shoshanna Brooker (D) on the general election ballot. The two partisan candidates were joined by independent Daniel Everson on the November ballot.[70]

    General election

    General Division

    Shoshanna Brooker
    Mark Kerenyi
    Daniel Everson

    Primary election

    General Division[71]

    Shoshanna Brooker Democratic Party
    Flite Freimann Republican Party
    John Halliday Republican Party
    Mark Kerenyi Republican Party

    Wayne

    Wayne County

    Republican incumbents Corey Spitler and Mark Wiest were unopposed in their party's primary, and no Democratic candidates filed for the race. Both were unopposed in the general election, as well, as no nonpartisan candidates filed for that race.

    General election

    General Division (Two seats)

    Corey Spitler (i)
    Mark Wiest (i)

    Primary election

    General Division (Two seats)[72]

    Corey Spitler Republican Party (i)
    Mark Wiest Republican Party (i)

    Wood

    Wood County

    General and Domestic Relations Division incumbent Judge Robert C. Pollex (R) did not file to seek re-election. Matthew Reger defeated Corey Speweik in the Republican primary. Reger faced Steve Long (D) in the general election. No independent candidates filed for the November contest.

    General election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions

    Steve Long Democratic Party
    Matthew Reger Republican Party

    Primary election

    General and Domestic Relations Divisions[73]

    Steve Long Democratic Party
    Matthew Reger Republican Party
    Corey Speweik Republican Party

    Wyandot

    Wyandot County

    Incumbent Judge Kathleen Aubry (R) was unopposed in the primary election. She was also unopposed in the general election on November 8, 2016, as no independent or Democratic candidates filed to challenge her.

    General election

    Kathleen Aubry Republican Party (i)

    Primary election

    Kathleen Aubry Republican Party (i)[74]

    No court of common pleas elections

    No court of common pleas elections

    Thirty-one counties had no court of common pleas seats up for election in 2016. Those counties were:

    Analysis

    Primary races

    More than three-quarters of the incumbents up for re-election in 2016 on Ohio's courts of common pleas ran for new terms in the partisan primaries. The remaining open seats saw at least one partisan candidate file for their respective elections with the exception of Monroe County, which saw no partisan candidates file for its General/Domestic Relations Division seat.

    The vast majority of the partisan candidates—incumbents and challengers—saw unopposed primary races. Republican candidates outnumbered Democrats, both when examining the number of incumbents running for re-election and the overall candidate pool.

    Election rules

    Primary election

    In Ohio, primary elections serve to nominate a candidate of a political party for election to an office. The winners of each party's primary go on to face each other in the general election. Primaries are held "on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in May of each year except in years in which a presidential primary election is held."[75]

    Selection method

    See also: Nonpartisan election of judges

    The 391 judges of the Ohio Courts of Common Pleas are all selected in an identical manner. Qualified individuals wishing to join the bench must participate in partisan primary elections followed by nonpartisan general elections.[76]

    The chief judges of the Ohio Courts of Common Pleas are chosen by peer vote and serve for one year.[76]

    Qualifications
    To serve on an appellate or general jurisdiction court, a judge must be:[76]

    • a district or county resident (for court of appeals and common pleas judges);
    • at least six years practiced in law; and
    • under the age of 70.

    Under the Ohio Constitution, a judge who reaches 70 years of age may be assigned by the chief justice to active duty, receiving payment on a per-day basis in addition to whatever retirement benefits he or she is entitled to.

    Recent news

    The link below is to the most recent stories in a Google news search for the terms Ohio judicial election. These results are automatically generated from Google. Ballotpedia does not curate or endorse these articles.

    See also

    External links

    Footnotes

    1. Ohio Secretary of State, "2016 Ohio Candidate Requirement Guide," accessed December 7, 2015
    2. The Ledger Independent, "Adams County 2016 primary candidate list official," December 25, 2015
    3. The Ledger Independent, "Adams County 2016 primary candidate list official," December 25, 2015
    4. 4.0 4.1 4.2 4.3 Allen County Board of Elections, "Primary Election-March 15, 2016," accessed January 15, 2016
    5. Ashland County Board of Elections, "March 2016 Primary Election Candidate Listing," accessed January 15, 2016
    6. The Post, "No contested elections for Athens County officials in 2016," January 19, 2016
    7. Auglaize County Board of Elections, "Election Notice for Use with the Federal Write-in Absentee Ballot," accessed January 21, 2016
    8. 8.0 8.1 8.2 8.3 8.4 8.5 Butler County Board of Elections, "Candidate and Issue List," January 13, 2016
    9. Clark County Board of Elections, "Certified Candidate Report," December 16, 2015
    10. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Tonia Blackburn, Clermont County Board of Elections," April 11, 2016
    11. 11.0 11.1 11.2 Clermont County Board of Elections, "Candidates Certified for March 15, 2016 Primary Election," accessed January 19, 2016
    12. Nick Katers, "Email exchange with county elections director Adam Booth," January 22, 2016
    13. Coschocton Beacon Today, "Primary election filings announced," December 17, 2015
    14. 14.0 14.1 14.2 14.3 14.4 14.5 Cuyahoga County Board of Elections, "Candidate List," accessed January 19, 2016
    15. Darke County Board of Elections, "Candidates List," accessed January 19, 2016
    16. ThisWeek, "Fourth judge will focus on divorce, custody cases," October 5, 2015
    17. Delaware County Board of Elections, "Primary Election - March 15, 2016," accessed January 21, 2016
    18. Erie County Board of Elections, "Primary Election - March 15, 2016," accessed January 21, 2016
    19. Fayette County Board of Elections, "Official Republican Primary Ballot," accessed January 20, 2016
    20. 20.0 20.1 Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Jeff Mackey," April 14, 2016
    21. 21.0 21.1 21.2 21.3 Franklin County Board of Elections, "2016 Primary Certified Candidates List," accessed January 20, 2016
    22. Fulton County Board of Elections, "Primary Election - March 15, 2016," December 16, 2015
    23. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with the Gallia County Board of Elections," April 11, 2016
    24. Gallia County Board of Elections, "2016 Primary Candidates," accessed January 20, 2016
    25. Geauga County Board of Elections, "Geauga County Certified Candidates for March 15, 2016 Primary Election," accessed January 22, 2016
    26. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Llyn McCoy, Green County Board of Elections," April 12, 2016
    27. 27.0 27.1 27.2 Greene County Board of Elections, "Official Certified Candidates List," accessed January 20, 2016
    28. Guernsey County Board of Elections, "Current Election Candidates & Issues, View Sample Ballot," accessed January 20, 2016
    29. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Paulette Leeper, Hamilton County Board of Elections Candidate and Issue Filing Services," May 10, 2016
    30. 30.0 30.1 30.2 30.3 30.4 30.5 Hamilton County Board of Elections, "March 2016 Election," accessed January 20, 2016
    31. Hardin County Board of Elections, "Military and Overseas Voters," accessed January 21, 2016
    32. 32.0 32.1 32.2 Nick Katers, "Email exchange with Henry County Board of Elections," accessed January 22, 2016
    33. The Jackson County Times-Journal, "Two Commissioners challenged for seats in Primary Election," December 19, 2015
    34. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with the Knox County Board of Elections," April 11, 2016
    35. Knox County Board of Elections, "Candidates Filing for Office," accessed January 20, 2016
    36. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Director Gloria M. Carson, Licking County Board of Election," April 13, 2016
    37. Licking County Board of Elections, "Primary Election-March 15, 2016," accessed January 20, 2016
    38. 38.0 38.1 Bellefontaine Examiner, "Commissioner race only local contest on March ballot," December 17, 2015
    39. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with David Stambol, Lorain County Board of Elections," April 11, 2016
    40. 40.0 40.1 40.2 40.3 Lorain County Board of Elections, "2016 Primary: Candidate List," January 5, 2016
    41. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Marty Limmer, Lucas County Board of Elections," May 2, 2015
    42. Lucas County Board of Elections, "Candidates List," January 12, 2016
    43. Madison County Board of Elections, "Petition Pickup List and Filing List," accessed January 21, 2016
    44. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Danielle O'Neill," April 11, 2016
    45. Mahoning County Board of Elections, "Candidates and Issues List," accessed January 21, 2016
    46. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with the Marion County Board of Elections," May 13, 2016
    47. Marion County Board of Elections, "Election Notice for Use with the Federal Write-in Absentee Ballot," accessed January 31, 2016
    48. Medina County Board of Elections, "Filings Certified," accessed January 21, 2016
    49. Mercer County Board of Elections, "Election Notice for Use with the Federal Write-in Absentee Ballot," accessed January 31, 2016
    50. 50.0 50.1 Montgomery County Board of Elections, "March 15, 2016 Montgomery County Presidential Primary Candidates Report," accessed January 21, 2016
    51. Nick Katers, "Email exchange with Penny Porter," January 25, 2016
    52. Muskingum County Board of Elections, "Primary Election - March 15, 2016," January 6, 2016
    53. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Deputy Janet Commers, Paulding County Board of Elections," April 11, 2016
    54. Paulding County Board of Elections, "March 15, 2016 - Primary Election," accessed January 21, 2016
    55. Pike County Board of Elections, "Candidates and Issues," accessed January 21, 2016
    56. 56.0 56.1 Portage County Board of Elections, "Candidate List," accessed January 21, 2016
    57. Nick Katers, "Email exchange with Putnam County Board of Elections," January 22, 2016
    58. 58.0 58.1 58.2 58.3 58.4 58.5 Richland County Board of Elections, "Candidate List & Questions and Issues," accessed January 21, 2016
    59. Ross County Board of Elections, "Local Candidates for the March 2016 Primary," accessed January 21, 2016
    60. WTSC, "Focht, Stacy seek county seat," accessed January 22, 2016
    61. 61.0 61.1 61.2 61.3 Stark County Board of Elections, "Candidates List," accessed January 21, 2016
    62. 62.0 62.1 62.2 Summit County Board of Elections, "Primary Election-March 15, 2016," accessed January 21, 2016
    63. Summit County Prosecuting Attorney Sherri Bevan Walsh, "Letter to Summit County Board of Elections, Re: Vacancy in Common Please Court (Prosecutor's Opinion 16-021)," April 7, 2016
    64. Akron Beacon Journal, "Scot Stevenson chosen for Common Pleas judge seat, will face Joy Malek Oldfield in November," June 17, 2016
    65. Trumbull County Board of Elections, "Declaration of Candidacy Petitions," January 4, 2016
    66. Tuscarawas County Board of Elections, "Candidates-March 15, 2016," accessed January 15, 2016
    67. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with the Van Wert County Board of Elections' office," March 4, 2016
    68. The Telegram News, "Two contests set in 2016 Vinton County Primary," December 22, 2015
    69. 69.0 69.1 69.2 69.3 Warren County Board of Elections, "2016 Primary Petitions-Board Certified," January 12, 2016
    70. Margaret Koenig, "Email correspondence with Washington County Board of Elections Director Tara Hupp," April 11, 2016
    71. The News Center, "New names file for office in Washington County primary," December 17, 2015
    72. Wayne County Board of Elections, "Certified Candidates," accessed January 15, 2016
    73. Wood County Board of Elections, "Certified Candidate List," accessed January 15, 2016
    74. Nick Katers, "Email exchange with Wyandot County Board of Elections," January 26, 2016
    75. Ohio Revised Code, "3501.01 Election procedure - election officials definitions," accessed May 4, 2014
    76. 76.0 76.1 76.2 American Judicature Society, "Methods of Judicial Selection: Ohio," archived October 3, 2014