Help us improve in just 2 minutes—share your thoughts in our reader survey.
Wave elections (1918-2016)/Presidential waves
House waves • Senate waves • Gubernatorial waves • State legislative waves |
Competitiveness in State Legislatures |
June 19, 2018
By: Rob Oldham and Jacob Smith
The 2018 elections could feature offsetting wave elections, which is when a wave against the president's party and a wave toward the president's party happen in the same year.
A wave toward the president's party, also known as a presidential wave election, is the opposite of a wave against the president's party, which is what this report has primarily discussed. Presidential wave elections are those in the bottom quintile of elections since 1918, usually where the president's party gained seats or suffered minimal losses.
The president's party needs to win nine U.S. House seats, two U.S. Senate seats, and 108 state legislative seats to have presidential wave elections in each group. It needs to at least hold even in gubernatorial races, neither winning nor losing any seats.
The 2018 offsetting waves could occur if Republicans lose 48 or more U.S. House seats and win two U.S. Senate seats, which is plausible because Democrats are defending 10 Senate seats in states Trump won in the 2016 election.
There have been four offsetting wave elections since 1918, and all involved offsetting U.S. Senate and gubernatorial waves. See the chart below for more information. Click here to see the full dataset.
Offsetting wave elections | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | Wave against president | Seat change | Wave toward president | Seat change |
1926 | Coolidge | R | First midterm[1] | U.S. Senate | -7 | Gubernatorial | +7 |
1970 | Nixon | R | First midterm | Gubernatorial | -12 | U.S. Senate | +3 |
1982 | Reagan | R | First midterm | Gubernatorial | -7 | U.S. Senate | +2 |
1986 | Reagan | R | Second midterm | U.S. Senate | -8 | Gubernatorial | +8 |
The graph below maps election years based on percentage changes in U.S. House and U.S. Senate seats. The graph is divided into four quadrants:
- Q1 contains years where the president's party saw an increase in its share of U.S. Senate seats and an increase in its share of U.S. House seats.
- Q2 contains years where the president's party saw an increase in its share of U.S. Senate seats and a decrease in its share of U.S. House seats.
- Q3 contains years where the president's party saw a decrease in its share of U.S. Senate seats and a decrease in its share of U.S. House seats.
- Q4 contains years where the president's party saw a decrease in its share of U.S. Senate seats and an increase in its share of U.S. House seats.
Click on the boxes below to see the presidential wave elections (the 20 percent of elections where the president's party performed best) since 1918 in U.S. House, U.S. Senate, gubernatorial, and state legislative elections as well as the 20 percent of election years with the highest composite scores.
U.S. House presidential wave elections | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | House seats change | ||
1948 | Truman | D | Presidential | +75 | ||
1964 | Johnson | D | Presidential | +37 | ||
1928 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +30 | ||
1944 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +24 | ||
1924 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +22 | ||
1960 | Eisenhower | R | Presidential | +21 | ||
1984 | Reagan | R | Presidential | +16 | ||
1972 | Nixon | R | Presidential | +12 | ||
1936 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +12 | ||
1992 | George H.W. Bush | R | Presidential | +9 | ||
1934 | Roosevelt | D | First midterm | +9 |
U.S. Senate presidential wave elections | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | Senate seats change | ||
1934 | Roosevelt | D | First midterm | +10 | ||
1928 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +8 | ||
1948 | Truman | D | Presidential | +8 | ||
1936 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +4 | ||
1960 | Eisenhower | R | Presidential | +4 | ||
1962 | Kennedy | D | First midterm | +4 | ||
2000 | Clinton | D | Presidential | +4 | ||
1970 | Nixon | R | First midterm | +3 | ||
2004 | George W. Bush | R | Presidential | +3 | ||
1924 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +2 | ||
1982 | Reagan | R | First midterm | +2 | ||
1966 | Lyndon Johnson | D | Presidential | +2 | ||
2016 | Obama | D | Presidential | +2 |
Gubernatorial presidential wave elections | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | Gubernatorial seats change | ||
1986 | Reagan | R | Second midterm | +8 | ||
1926 | Coolidge | R | First midterm[1] | +7 | ||
1928 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +7 | ||
1948 | Truman | D | Presidential | +6 | ||
1924 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +3 | ||
1944 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +3 | ||
1984 | Reagan | R | Presidential | +2 | ||
1934 | Roosevelt | D | First midterm | +1 | ||
2000 | Clinton | D | Presidential | +1 | ||
1936 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | 0 | ||
1960 | Eisenhower | R | Presidential | 0 | ||
1964 | Johnson | D | Presidential | 0 | ||
1996 | Clinton | D | Presidential | 0 | ||
2004 | George W. Bush | R | Presidential | 0 |
State legislative presidential wave elections | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | State legislative seats change | ||
1948 | Truman | D | Presidential | +745 | ||
1964 | Johnson | D | Presidential | +530 | ||
1924 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +522 | ||
1984 | Reagan | R | Presidential | +358 | ||
1960 | Eisenhower | R | Presidential | +315 | ||
1928 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +169 | ||
1940 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +129 | ||
1944 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +121 | ||
2002 | George W. Bush | R | First midterm | +110 | ||
1992 | George H.W. Bush | R | Presidential | +108 |
Composite presidential wave elections | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Year | President | Party | Election type | Overall score | ||
1948 | Truman | D | Presidential | +17.8% | ||
1928 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +13.4% | ||
1934 | Roosevelt | D | First midterm | +9.4% | ||
1924 | Coolidge | R | Presidential | +6.7% | ||
1984 | Reagan | R | Presidential | +5.6% | ||
1960 | Eisenhower | R | Presidential | +5.4% | ||
1964 | Johnson | D | Presidential | +5.4% | ||
2000 | Clinton | D | Presidential | +5.1% | ||
1944 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +4.1% | ||
1936 | Roosevelt | D | Presidential | +3.7% |
Click here to read the report as one page.
Click here to read or download the report as a PDF.
Footnotes